Most likely cause

Overwatering is the top cause of yellow Calathea leaves. Calatheas like steady, light moisture but they will not tolerate sitting in wet soil, and roots deprived of air quickly begin to rot and fail to feed the leaves.

You can confirm it by the pattern. Overwatering yellows the lowest, oldest leaves first, the affected leaves feel soft rather than crispy, and the soil stays wet for days. If the pot has no drainage or sits in a full saucer, this is almost certainly the driver. Let the soil dry to the top inch and the yellowing should stop spreading.

Other causes

These rank below overwatering but often overlap with it.

  • Natural aging. A single old lower leaf yellowing slowly is normal; only the bottommost leaf is affected and the rest look healthy.
  • Underwatering. Prolonged drought stresses the roots; the soil is bone dry, leaves yellow alongside crispy edges, and the soil pulls from the pot.
  • Too much direct sun. Harsh light bleaches the foliage; look for pale yellow patches on the side facing the window.
  • Nutrient deficiency. Old, spent soil runs short on feed; the whole plant pales to an even yellow across many leaves.

How to fix it

  1. Check the soil. Feel the top inch. If it is wet, hold off watering until it dries.
  2. Improve drainage. Make sure the pot drains freely and empty any saucer so roots never sit in water.
  3. Water consistently. Water when the top inch is slightly dry, using room-temperature filtered or distilled water.
  4. Remove spent leaves. Cut fully yellow leaves at the base with clean scissors to redirect energy.
  5. Adjust the light. Move the plant to bright indirect light, out of direct sun.
  6. Refresh feeding. During active growth, feed at quarter strength every few weeks if the soil is old.
CauseTell-tale signFix
OverwateringSoft lower leaves, wet soilLet top inch dry, improve drainage
Natural agingSingle oldest leaf onlyTrim it, no action needed
UnderwateringBone-dry soil, crispy edgesWater thoroughly, keep evenly moist
Direct sunPale patches facing windowMove to bright indirect light
Nutrient deficiencyEven pale yellowing overallFeed at quarter strength